Chapter 6: Question Two: What Is the True Objective?

Chapter 6 · Part Two: The Comfort Check

I’ve sat in a marketing review where every number on the board was green and the company was invisible.

Content shipped on schedule. MQLs above target. Webinar registration up year over year. Site traffic up. Event program delivered on budget. Nine slides, every one of them honest, and not one person in that room could have told you what a buyer in our market would say about us if you stopped them in a hallway and asked.

Nobody was lying. Nobody was even spinning. Every one of those numbers was a real measurement of a real thing that really happened.

They were just all measurements of activity, and the company’s problem wasn’t an activity problem.


The tell

Here’s the test, and it’s the most useful single sentence in this chapter:

If you could achieve it completely while the business got worse, it’s an activity.

Run it on anything.

Generate qualified pipeline. You can generate an enormous amount of qualified pipeline at a company that’s losing ground, because pipeline is a measure of how much you put in the top, not of whether anybody chooses you at the bottom. Activity.

Publish twelve pieces of content this quarter. Obviously an activity, and it doesn’t even resist the test.

Have a presence at the show. Activity, and a particularly expensive one, because “presence” is a word that exists specifically so that nobody has to define the outcome.

Be one of the three companies a CISO names when a peer asks who to look at. Not an activity. You can’t do that while the business gets worse, because it’s a description of a state of the world outside your building. That’s an objective.

Notice what the good one has that the others don’t. It describes something that happens in somebody else’s head, in a room you aren’t in. Almost every real marketing objective has that shape, and almost no marketing metric does.


Why activities win anyway

Not because people are foolish. Because activities are better in three specific ways that matter enormously to the person who has to survive the quarter.

  1. Activities are completable. You can finish them. There’s a satisfying moment when the thing ships. Outcomes don’t finish, they trend, and trending is a terrible experience to be evaluated on.
  2. Activities are attributable. My team did this. The activity has your name on it in a way that “the market thinks about us differently” never will, and if you’re three levels down in a large organization, attributable is how you get promoted.
  3. Activities are schedulable. You can put an activity in a plan in October and know exactly what March looks like. You can’t schedule the market changing its mind.

So the pull toward activities isn’t laziness either. It’s a rational response to how people are actually evaluated. Which means the fix isn’t to shame anybody for tracking activities. The fix is to make sure there’s an outcome sitting above them that the activities are supposed to produce, and to check periodically whether they’re producing it.

That’s the whole job of question two. Not to ban activity metrics. To stop them from being the top of the stack.


Know what you want. From my 2022 CyberMarketingCon keynote.

The Definition of Done rewrite

The exercise. Take what each function in your organization says it delivers, and rewrite it as the outcome it was supposed to produce.

Then look at the third column, because that’s where this stops being a semantic exercise and starts costing something.

Function What it says it delivers The outcome it was supposed to produce What changes if you adopt the second one
Demand generation Qualified leads, delivered to sales A first conversation that’s worth the buyer’s time You now care about what happens after the handoff, which means you need to see the meeting, which means you need a relationship with sales you may not currently have
Content Published assets on a calendar A buyer can explain what you do to a colleague You measure repetition, not consumption, and most of your calendar turns out to be producing neither
Brand A refreshed identity, a campaign, a look People recall and can describe you, months after exposure You have to baseline before you spend and measure after you stop, which is Chapter 9
Events Booth, meetings booked, scans Somebody remembers a specific thing about you on the flight home The demo station becomes negotiable, and the budget moves toward whatever produces the memory
Marketing ops Systems running, data clean, process followed The rest of the organization can answer questions it couldn’t answer before Reporting stops being a deliverable and becomes an instrument, and some of the dashboards die
Product marketing Messaging, launch, enablement assets Sales says the same true sentence without reading it off a card You test by listening to calls rather than by counting asset downloads
Analyst relations Briefings held, reports appeared in An analyst describes you accurately to a client when you aren’t in the room The fifty-slide deck becomes actively counterproductive, because nobody repeats slide thirty-one

Every row in that third column costs something. That isn’t a flaw in the exercise, it’s the exercise. An outcome you can adopt without changing anything was an activity in disguise.


How to write one somebody can fail

A real objective has four parts. Miss any one and you’ve written a slogan.

1. A change, stated as a change. Not a state, a delta. “Be known in the mid-market” is a wish. “Move from a market where nine in ten of our buyers have never heard of us to one where four in ten have” is a change. It has a direction and a distance.

2. In somebody else’s head or behavior. Outside your building. If the objective can be satisfied entirely by things your team does, you’ve written an activity with ambition.

3. A named measurement, chosen before you start. Not “we’ll figure out how to measure this.” The measurement is part of the objective, and choosing it afterward is how you end up with a metric selected for its willingness to agree with you.

4. A date, and a person. When we look, and who decides what the number meant.

Put together, it reads like a boring sentence, and that’s correct. Objectives should be boring. The interesting part is question three.

By the end of Q3, aided recall among security leaders at companies of one to five thousand employees moves from 9 percent to above 25 percent, measured by the same survey instrument we baselined with, and I make the call on whether that worked.

Somebody can fail that. That’s the only property that matters.


The thing everybody does instead

Writes the objective after the plan.

You know how this goes because you’ve done it, and so have I. Somebody has an idea. The idea is good and everybody wants to do it. A deck gets built. Two slides from the end, somebody says we should add the success metrics, and a person who wasn’t in the original conversation is asked to go find some numbers that this activity would plausibly move.

That isn’t measurement. That’s a costume.

The giveaway is that you can always tell which slide was written last, because it’s the one where the metrics are all things the plan was already going to produce.

Question two has to be answered before question three or the whole check is theater. This is the single most common way I see this tool used badly, including by me, including recently.


Back to Axonius

The signal from Chapter 5 said the constraint had moved. The old objective, which nobody had written down because it was structural rather than stated, was something like “help twelve enterprise reps work twelve accounts each extremely well.”

The new objective had to describe the new constraint, and the new constraint was that a market that was already coming to us mostly didn’t know we existed.

So: get known by the mid-market, at a scale an enterprise motion can’t reach, and know whether it happened.

That last clause is a third of the objective and it’s the part that made the rest of it possible to fund. I’ll come back to it in Chapter 9 in detail, because “know whether it happened” turned out to be the hardest and most valuable decision in the entire campaign, and it got made before a dollar was spent, which is the only time it can be made honestly.

Question three is what we did about it, and it started with an arbitrary rule I gave myself that made no sense at the time.


The Comfort Check

Chapter 6: the marketing review

1. The comfortable assumption. If every number is green, marketing is working.

2. The true objective. Know whether anything we did changed what the market believes, rather than whether we completed what we planned.

3. The redesigned approach. One outcome at the top of the stack, stated as a change in somebody else’s head, with its measurement chosen before the work starts and a named person who calls it.