Chapter 5 · Part Two: The Comfort Check
Bigger company, more devices, bigger problem, bigger budget.
That was the assumption at Axonius, and I held it as firmly as anybody. The product was asset management, which at the time meant knowing what you have and whether it’s actually protected. So the logic ran straight downhill: an enterprise has more of everything, therefore more of the problem, therefore more willingness to pay, therefore sell enterprise.
We built the entire company around that sentence. Reps who knew twelve accounts each and could make a number on four deals. A sales cycle measured in quarters. Marketing built to support a small number of very large conversations.
I want to say clearly that this was a good assumption. Not a lazy one, not a stupid one. If you had put it in front of any experienced person in our industry, they would have nodded, and they would have been right to.
That’s the whole problem with it.
A comfortable assumption isn’t a bad idea. It’s a good idea that has stopped being examined. The bad ideas get caught. Somebody always catches the bad ideas. What nobody catches is the reasonable belief that quietly became load-bearing for twenty other decisions while everyone’s attention was elsewhere.
Why you can’t see them
Three reasons, and they stack.
They were true when you adopted them. Almost every comfortable assumption in your organization was correct at the moment somebody formed it. That’s why it’s still there. It has a track record. It has, in the most literal sense, worked. The question is never whether it was true. The question is whether the conditions that made it true are still the conditions you’re operating in, and nobody checks that, because checking requires you to suspect something that has never let you down.
Nobody ever said them out loud. This is the structural part. A decision that got debated has a record, a rationale, and usually an owner who will defend it, which means it’s available for review. An assumption that never got debated has none of those things. It got absorbed. It’s in the org chart, in the budget lines, in the shape of the nav bar, in what the calendar looks like in March. You can’t audit a belief that was never stated, which is why the first half of this chapter is about getting them stated.
Questioning them is socially expensive. If a belief has been operating unexamined for three years, then examining it implies that three years of work was built on something nobody checked, which implicates everybody in the room including the person asking. The tool in Chapter 4 exists mostly to make that cheap.
So here’s the working definition, and the test that goes with it.
A comfortable assumption is a belief your organization acts on, that nobody in the room could name the meeting for.
If you can name the meeting where it was decided, it isn’t one.
The Assumption Inventory
Four methods. Run all four and you’ll have more than you can act on, which is the correct outcome. The point isn’t to overturn them. Most of them are fine. The point is to have them written down somewhere so that when conditions change, you have a list to check instead of a feeling.
1. The “just how it works” sweep (30 minutes, with your team)
Ask everyone to write down, silently, five things about how your marketing operates that they would describe to a new hire with the phrase “that’s just how it works here.”
Silently is doing real work in that sentence. Said out loud, the first answer anchors the room and you get five variations of it.
Then read them out without attribution. The ones that appear on three or more lists are your operating assumptions, and the fact that everyone independently reached for the same ones means they’re invisible rather than agreed.
2. The new-hire question (free, and you have about thirty days to use it)
Every person who joins your team arrives with a functioning ability to see your assumptions, and loses it in roughly a month. This is the single most underused asset in a marketing organization and it expires on a schedule.
So use it deliberately. In week three, ask: what have we done since you got here that you wouldn’t have done at your last company, and what did we not do that you expected?
Write the answers down. Don’t defend any of them in the moment, which is the hard part, because about half will be things you already considered and rejected for good reasons. Defending them in the meeting teaches the new person that the question was ceremonial and you’ll never get an honest answer from them again.
3. Budget archaeology (an afternoon, once a year, before planning)
Take last year’s budget, line by line. For each line above some threshold you care about, answer two questions in writing:
- What was this originally for?
- Who decided to fund it the first time, and is that person still here?
The lines where nobody can answer either question aren’t investments. They’re inherited furniture. In my experience this exercise finds between ten and twenty percent of a marketing budget that exists because it existed, and that money is the cheapest funding available for anything new, because it’s already yours and nobody has to approve it.
4. The calendar audit (an hour)
Look at the twelve months. For every recurring thing on it, a report, a show, a campaign season, a webinar series, ask: what made that the right interval?
Annual threat reports are annual because the first one was, and because the word “annual” was in the title, and for no other reason I have ever been able to find. Quarterly campaigns are quarterly because the finance calendar is quarterly, which is a fact about accounting, not about buyers.
Anything on your calendar whose rhythm you can’t justify is being set by something other than your market.
Forty comfortable assumptions in cybersecurity marketing
This is the reference section. You won’t believe all of these are assumptions, and for your company several of them will turn out to be correct after examination, which is a fine outcome and the point of examining them.
Each one comes with the counter-question, because the assumption alone just makes you feel bad. The question is what gives you something to do.
Brand and positioning
| The comfortable assumption | The counter-question |
|---|---|
| 1. We have to be in the category the analysts named. | What would we call this if no analyst had ever named it? |
| 2. Our differentiation is our technology. | Can a buyer perceive that difference before they buy? |
| 3. The homepage is for buyers. | Who actually lands there, and what did they come to confirm? |
| 4. We need to sound enterprise-ready. | Who decided that sounding like everybody else is what ready sounds like? |
| 5. The founders’ origin story is our brand. | Does that story change what a buyer believes, or does it only explain us to ourselves? |
Content
| The comfortable assumption | The counter-question |
|---|---|
| 6. The threat report is an annual thing. | What made twelve months the right interval, other than the last one being twelve months ago? |
| 7. More content produces more pipeline. | Which piece from last year can anybody on the team name without looking? |
| 8. Gating the asset is how we get the lead. | What did we actually gain, measured against who didn’t download it? |
| 9. Thought leadership means a byline from an executive. | Who in our company do practitioners already read voluntarily? |
| 10. We should publish on the topics with search volume. | Who else is publishing on those, and how would a reader tell ours apart? |
Demand generation
| The comfortable assumption | The counter-question |
|---|---|
| 11. A lead is the unit of work. | What’s the first thing that happens after a lead exists, and is it any good? |
| 12. The webinar needs a thirty-minute presentation. | Would anybody attend if we only did the Q&A? |
| 13. We need a nurture sequence. | What would a real person say they got out of email four? |
| 14. Paid search on the category term is table stakes. | What are we paying to be the eleventh identical result for? |
| 15. MQL thresholds should be tuned quarterly. | When did we last ask a rep what a good first meeting actually feels like? |
Events
| The comfortable assumption | The counter-question |
|---|---|
| 16. We need a booth at the show. | What’s a booth for, and can anybody name something that came from last year’s? |
| 17. The booth needs a demo station. | What’s the actual conversion event here, and does it require a screen? |
| 18. Swag drives traffic. | Traffic of whom? |
| 19. We should sponsor the party. | What does somebody remember about us the next morning? |
| 20. Field events are a regional sales motion. | Who owns whether anybody in that room ever buys anything? |
Analyst relations and press
| The comfortable assumption | The counter-question |
|---|---|
| 21. The analyst needs a fifty-slide deck. | What do they need to be able to repeat to a client next week, unprompted? |
| 22. Being in the report is the goal. | What happens to a company that’s in the report and can’t be described? |
| 23. Press releases are how news travels. | Where did our buyer actually hear about us last time? |
| 24. We need an embargo. | Who does the embargo benefit, us or the outlet? |
| 25. Analyst relations is a CMO activity. | Who in our company can answer the hard technical question in the briefing? |
Product marketing
| The comfortable assumption | The counter-question |
|---|---|
| 26. The messaging house has to be complete before we launch. | Which single sentence would we keep if we could keep only one? |
| 27. Feature parity closes deals. | When did we last lose on a feature rather than on a story? |
| 28. Battlecards should cover every competitor. | Which three actually show up, and what do reps say when we aren’t listening? |
| 29. The launch is the moment. | What happens in week six? |
| 30. We need a category. | Do we need a category, or do we need one sentence a buyer can repeat correctly? |
Sales enablement
| The comfortable assumption | The counter-question |
|---|---|
| 31. Sales needs more content. | Which asset actually gets sent, and what do reps send instead of the ones we made? |
| 32. Training is an event. | What do reps do differently on the Tuesday after? |
| 33. The pitch deck should tell our whole story. | What does the buyer need to believe first, before any of it matters? |
| 34. Marketing’s job ends at the handoff. | Who owns whether the first meeting is worth the buyer’s time? |
| 35. Objection handling is a document. | Where does the objection actually get raised, and is anybody from marketing ever there? |
Operations and measurement
| The comfortable assumption | The counter-question |
|---|---|
| 36. Attribution tells us what worked. | What decision would we make differently if the model changed tomorrow? |
| 37. We measure what the platform reports. | What would we measure if the platform didn’t exist? |
| 38. Brand can’t be measured. | What did we decide to measure before we started? |
| 39. The dashboard is the review. | When did a number on it last change a plan? |
| 40. More data will settle this. | Is this a data problem, or a disagreement about the objective wearing a data costume? |
Back to Axonius
The assumption held for a while and then the market started arguing with it.
Mid-market companies, roughly one to five thousand employees, began coming to us inbound. We weren’t calling them. They found us. They closed inside a quarter, and this is the detail that matters more than the volume: they closed without asking for a discount.
Anybody can generate inbound. Inbound tells you your content works. Closing at list price is the market telling you it wants what you have badly enough not to negotiate, and that’s a different signal entirely.
Nobody planned for that. It just kept happening, until it stopped being an anomaly and started being data.
Here’s what a signal like that doesn’t tell you. It doesn’t tell you to sell harder to the mid-market. That’s the small version of the conclusion, and it’s the one an organization reaches naturally because it requires changing nothing.
It tells you your model is wrong.
An enterprise motion is built to reach twelve people extraordinarily well. A commercial motion has to reach ten thousand people well enough. Those aren’t the same machine with a different target list. They have different economics, different content, different sales roles, and critically, a different constraint.
Which is what the signal was actually about. The constraint had moved. The question was no longer whether our reps could close. It was whether anybody knew we existed.
That’s question one doing its job. Not producing an answer, producing a better question. What Chapter 6 does with that better question is where the campaign came from.
The Comfort Check
Chapter 5: the Axonius go-to-market
1. The comfortable assumption. Bigger company, more devices, bigger problem, bigger budget. Sell enterprise.
2. The true objective. Get known by a market that was already coming to us, at a scale an enterprise sales motion can’t reach.
3. The redesigned approach. Continued in Chapter 6.