Appendix E: Deriving an Unpublished Rubric

Appendix E · Appendices

For any scored situation where the criteria exist but aren’t written down: a pitch contest, an analyst evaluation, a shortlist, an interview loop. Full method in Chapter 10.

  1. Collect ten to twenty past artifacts. Winners and losers.
  2. Extract the questions each section answered, not the answers.
  3. Count. The questions in every artifact are the real rubric. The ones only in the winners are the interesting part.
  4. Write the competent version of every answer. That’s the floor. You have to clear it.
  5. Satisfy the floor fast and spend the remainder on one thing built to be repeated.

The five questions I found in past Innovation Sandbox pitches:

  1. What’s the problem?
  2. Why is it big?
  3. What’s genuinely new?
  4. Why you?
  5. Can you survive the floodgates?

In three minutes, the one repeatable thing got about twenty seconds. That was enough.