Appendix B: The Sameness Audit

Appendix B · Appendices

Ninety minutes. Full method in Chapter 2.

  1. Pick the set (10 min). Eight to twelve companies a buyer meets in the same week as you: three or four direct competitors, two or three adjacent vendors, two or three from the last sponsor list, and your own company.
  2. Capture (20 min). Same browser, width, zoom and day. Light mode. Hero to just below the fold.
  3. Score four axes (40 min). Companies as rows.
    1. Vocabulary: every phrase in each headline and subhead, with a count of how many companies use it. Three or more means invisible.
    2. Structure: hero over image or gradient, short subhead, paired CTAs, logo bar, three-column benefits, stat band, testimonial carousel. Tick each.
    3. Navigation: top-level items, verbatim.
    4. Proof: what each offers as evidence. Note what almost nobody offers.
  4. The swap test (10 min). Six most similar heroes, logos stripped, shown to somebody outside marketing. Ask them to name the companies.
  5. Write the sentence. The one thing your category agrees on without ever voting. That’s what you’re working against.